The End of the World


christopher eccleston quits doctor whoTen years ago today, we were all watching episode two of series one, with a carnival of monsters, the debut of Zoe Wanamaker’s Cassandra, the Doctor flirting with a sexy talking tree and an ep that was pretty Douglas Adams-y in tone, only done proper with the right balance of jokes and drama.

 After the utter joy and elation of last week’s triumphant series opener Rose, by the time we all sat down to watch this we’d had the shocking news, the Thursday before this episode was broadcast, that The Miserable Northern Git was off after just one series, which was pretty disheartening as he was really bloody good. Will we ever really know the truth about what, besides Keith Boak, pissed off Eccleston so badly that he quit just as he’d started?

I doubt it, but my best guess is that the Execs, stuck in their Cardiff offices, mishandled the situation by letting their leading man feel that his concerns weren’t important enough to warrant the action he was calling for, whatever it was. They were probably up to their eyeballs in trying to stop the entire shoot going off the rails and underestimated how strongly Eccles felt about what was happening on the set. He, meanwhile, was sat in his trailer thinking “This is sh#t. Do I really want to go through another year of this? Nah.  F#ck it, I’m off. Sod `em.” Or maybe not.

Fandom’s collective reaction was an almighty WTAF? Was I the only one who was just the tiniest bit suspicious when Eccles appeared on the Doctor Who edition of Mastermind with John Humphryes and talked about the role in the past tense? It was still a shockeroonie when it was confirmed, but can you imagine how The Parting of the Ways would have gone down if they’d managed to keep it a secret!!!

Meanwhile, back on Platform One…

doctor who complete history 12It’s well known that Raffalo was a late addition when the episode was found to be under-running, so this edit dispenses with the services of the doomed blue space plumber. The scene where she gets dragged into the vent [how exactly do those tiny metal spiders manage that?] pretty much duplicates the scene with the Steward so I cut it, which meant a slight trim to the start of his scene to make sure the music didn’t jar. I also cut Rose’s reaction after phoning her mum as, even allowing for culture shock, she’s five billion years in the bloody future, what does she expect? Even she’s dead, never mind Jackie!

dwm506Something else that gets the chop is Eccles dodging the fans, by which I mean the ones in the story. Much like the rubbish “turning of the earth” speech the previous week, this sequence never really convinced me. Apart from anything else, like the sheer idiocy of the design, if you look closely you can see that he could easily slide under the bloody things. As storytelling obstacles go it’s not exactly the best is it, if anything it’s rather too literal, so it gets cut.

It’s here that we get our first real mention of The Time War, although it was mentioned in passing in Rose. It’s strange watching this again, now knowing what we know from The Day of The Doctor. That 2013 retcon that isn’t really a retcon changes our perspective on Eccles’ 2005 “survivor’s guilt” and makes it rather less dramatic, as we watch the poor old soul torturing himself over something we now know he didn’t do, even though he thought about it when he was John Hurt. We didn’t know that back then but we do now, with the result that the scene where Jabe feels sorry for him gets cut too, so that we can find out about the Dr’s troubled past at the same time as Rose does.

end of the world fan edit dr who

dr who end world cd rear

RTD downloads


2 thoughts on “The End of the World

  1. I admit to being disappointed by the fans and some other aspects when I first saw the original TX version, so this was another case when Whoflix’s editing choices are once again proven to be spot on. However, I disagree with the notion that The Day of the Doctor is a retcon as such: “You’re not actually suggesting we change our own personal history?” and “This time there’s three of us” make it clear to me at least that the first time around Dr Eccles really had just come out of a Gallifrey-destroying war where the War Dr really had pressed the button. So the survivor’s guilt here is real, storywise, as we’re seeing what happened after the last great time war before Bad Wolf Girl changes a critical detail.

    1. Glad you liked the edit, you’ve done some good work on YouTube, mirroring some of my own fixes. [Could have done with you back in the day, where the hell were you… ;-)]

      As for the survivor’s guilt, I think you’re wrong. My take on it is that everything happens at once, there is no past, present and future, there is only now. Time isn’t sequential in that sense, it’s all current. From the POV of an outside observer, all of time would be happening all at once. It’s not the case that Tennant happens, then Smith happens. Tennant and Smith and all the rest of the Doctors are all happening now, at the same time. It’s a bit like that shot in The Bells of Saint John where you get all the different people on those little screens all talking at the same time. That’s what the Doctor’s timeline is like, all of them are all happening now…

      So when Ten talks about changing their own personal history, ie Hurt not hitting the big red button, he’s talking about what, from his POV, is established history, what he thinks happened. Which is that Hurt did hit the big red button and destroyed Gallifrey, which is consistent with Hurt realising he won’t remember not destroying Gallifrey. He’s not talking about a slightly altered version of Sandshoes & Chinny’s past, that was always Sandshoes and Chinny’s past, he’s talking about the revelation of what actually happened. But his memories of it will default to what Eccles & Sandshoes & Smiffy all thought prior to The Day of the Doctor

      So The Moment didn’t actually change anything, the way things happened in TDOTD was always the way they happened. The post-Hurt Doctors simply forgot about it. It’s a retcon ‘cos it gives us new information we didn’t have in 2005 but it doesn’t rewrite Rose onwards and say that’s not how all those adventures happened. Think of The Moff as a storytelling Borusa, re-assuring the Doctor that his narrative stability will be maintained…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s