Black Orchid

Poor old Black Orchid, one of the most unloved stories and for good reason. It’s a mess and can’t make up it’s mind about what kind of story it is. It’s not really a historical but yet it’s not really the murder mystery it purports to be either. It`s a sort of 80’s stab at The Unicorn And The Wasp without the wasp. Okay so we have the deformed brother but, leaving aside the usual tedious “ugly people are nice too” debate, he isn’t really much of a villain. If they’d let him have some dialogue instead of making him mute that might have improved things a bit. But no.

Despite having some of the trappings of the old Agatha Christie country house murder mystery, it isn’t that kind of story either. If only there was a Not Poirot character, in the same way that there was a Not Bertie Basset character in The Happiness Patrol, to liven things up. You could have had a nice reversal with the great detective becoming the equivalent of Captain Hastings when faced with the “leetahl greh cells” of the monsieur le Docteur. But no, there’s no Hercules Parrot to enliven Le Orchid Noir.

Doctor Who meets Poirot!

As it is, there are some nice moments in it and some of the dialogue’s quite entertaining but the story is so thin it can’t even stretch to two episodes, which is why this Fan Edit ends up cutting it back to the equivalent of just one. I took the opportunity to reinstate some of the extended/deleted stuff from the DVD and dug out a piece of Test Card music to cover the journey to the cricket match and part of the match itself. Montages always help move things along and it was a fun sequence to cut together. When George enters the Doctor’s room to steal his costume [how does he know?], the scene seemed a bit empty so I borrowed a music cue from another Davison story. And again for when he burns the door down to escape. I’m sure you`ll be able to tell which one!

black orchid covers

And was it really necessary for Nyssa to have a duplicate? It would have made more sense if another actress had played Anne, one who was similar in appearance to Sarah Sutton. That would have made sense of poor old George’s tortured mind. If Nyssa and Anne look a lot alike you could understand him mistaking one for the other. But to have Sutton playing both parts is to misunderstand the role of the doppleganger in fiction. I mean, has Terence Dudley never seen Metropolis?

black orchid dwm



5 thoughts on “Black Orchid

  1. I had never seen very far into this one before––this edit makes it seem like one of the better Davison stories, which I don’t think is its reputation, so good job.

    I notice a lot of these end really quickly after the resolution of the plot. Is that a specific choice regardless of what’s there or do you just find the goodbyes and banter at the end are usually not good material?

    1. ’tis a choice. Unless there’s a particularly engaging “moment of charm” in the tag scene at the end I always find it best to end on a dramatic high point instead.

      1. While I appreciate the idea, it’s a little on the abrupt/jarring side sometimes regarding what happened to the Doctor and companions or supporting characters.

      2. which is why there’s nothing to stop you putting in the scenes you think I shouldn’t have missed out and making it your own!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.